# 50 Arthur Road, Islington

- **Decision:** dismissed, 28 August 2026
- **Decided by:** Planning Inspector: N Unwin
- **Authority:** Islington (London)
- **Appeal reference:** 6008065
- **Application reference:** P2025/2793/FUL
- **Procedure:** written-representations
- **Development:** First-floor rear and mansard extensions and change of use from small HMO (C4) to large HMO (sui generis), 3 extra rooms
- **Site context:** inside-settlement
- **Green Belt:** no
- **Framework applied:** August 2026 NPPF
- **Determinative policies:** s38(6), Islington DMP H2
- **Development plan policies:** Islington Local Plan Strategic and DM Policies 2023 H2, H10
- **Main issues:** supply of family housing
- **Tags:** tier-2, transitional-no-consultation, loss-of-housing, hmo, limited-nppf-engagement

## Summary
A small HMO was to be enlarged and changed into a large sui generis HMO. Dismissed as a loss of family housing under local policy H2. The loss arises because a C4 HMO can revert to a C3 house under PD rights, but a large HMO cannot (DL ¶6-10). The 2026 Framework was noted, but only the development plan was applied.

## What made the difference
The PD fallback runs one way. Keeping the property within C3/C4 preserves its potential as a family home. The appellant's intentions were irrelevant because "future owners may wish to" revert it (DL ¶9). The L2 substantial weight to more homes or floorspace was not argued or considered.

## Policy findings
- **H2 (Islington DMP): conflict.** C4 can revert to C3 family house under PD, sui generis large HMO cannot, so it is a loss of self-contained family housing without equivalent replacement (DL 6-10)

## Key facts
- Terraced three-storey house suitable as larger family housing (DL 5)
- Appellant's claim that the large HMO could later be reconverted via planning permission given limited weight (DL 9)
- 2026 Framework "does not change the planning policy context"; no Framework policy is cited in the reasoning (DL 2)

## Sources
- https://appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-appeal/appeals/6008065
- https://appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/published-document/093ae4f7-38aa-4126-b42a-8e6bfbbed787

---

Source: https://planningdistilled.org/research/england/nppf-navigator/decisions/PINS-6008065.html

A summary of a public planning decision, written from the decision letter. Not legal advice. © Planning Distilled. Released under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/): share and adapt freely, with credit to Planning Distilled. Quotations from decision letters, plans and the Framework remain the copyright of their publishers.