Research

England-wide analysis, reviews of individual local planning authorities, and case studies of particular settlements.

England

NPPF 2026 Navigator

An interactive decision route through the National Planning Policy Framework (August 2026): answer the facts and planning judgements a decision needs, see the verbatim policy text for each step, and compare with appeal and council decisions made under the new Framework. Not legal advice.

The decision route in full — Every question the NPPF 2026 Navigator asks, with the guidance drawn from decisions and the verbatim Framework text: the August 2026 NPPF decision route as one page.

Decision notes — 1064 planning decisions made in England since the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework took effect, each read and summarised with the policy findings, quotations and paragraph references. Free to reuse (CC BY 4.0).

Method & cross-references — How the NPPF 2026 Navigator was built, the dataset counts, external sources our notes have been checked against, and a summary of the inconsistencies the research has found.

NPPF 2026 Map

A map of the whole National Planning Policy Framework (August 2026): the decision route, every chapter and annex as a graph of its policies and their cross-references, every policy as a tree of its paragraphs and limbs, the verbatim text beside whatever you select, and a quick-nav box that finds a code such as S5(1)(j) and every place the Framework refers to it. 131 policies, 363 paragraphs, 616 limbs, 129 glossary terms, 168 cross-references.

How to assess a sustainable location under the 2026 NPPF

How to assess a sustainable location under the August 2026 NPPF: the test in policy TR3, how to read the Connectivity Tool, the transport guidance still awaited, the Planning Inspectorate webinar on the question, and the 800 metre and 400 metre distances used in practice. Every source listed.

The factors in decisions — The factors inspectors and councils used to decide whether a location is sustainable in 247 planning decisions made since the August 2026 NPPF: 55 factors in 11 classes, counted. The walking route was decisive in 117; footway presence and street lighting are among the most-used factors; distance cuts evenly.

Service village does not mean sustainable — A settlement hierarchy ranks villages for the plan. Under the August 2026 NPPF it cannot on its own decide whether a site is sustainable; the route does.

Sources — The 17 documents behind the Planning Distilled page on assessing a sustainable location under the August 2026 NPPF: the Framework, the Connectivity Tool guidance, the promised transport guidance, the Planning Inspectorate webinar, and earlier walking-distance guidance, each with its date, link and what it was used for.

What is a "settlement" under the 2026 NPPF?

What "settlement" means in the August 2026 NPPF: the Annex B definition and its four limbs, the 27 policies that hang a rule on the word, what follows for a hamlet or a village washed over by the Green Belt, whether a service-village tier makes any difference, and 41 decisions that have applied the definition, each with the sentence that decided it.

What is a "village" under the 2026 NPPF?

What "village", "town", "city", "hamlet", "parish" and "built-up area" mean for a planning decision under the August 2026 NPPF: who defines each word, what the Framework does with "village", how inspectors draw the line between a village and a hamlet (14 decisions), the statistical classifications sometimes cited, and Claverdon as a worked example.

"Very special circumstances" under the 2026 NPPF

What "very special circumstances" means in the August 2026 NPPF: the GB6(2) test, where it came from, how inspectors are trained to run it, when it applies (only after a proposal fails every GB7 category), what has and has not counted, and 85 decisions that applied it, each with the sentence that decided it.

"Substantially outweighed": the presumption under the 2026 NPPF

What "substantially outweighed" means in the August 2026 NPPF: the 8 places the words appear, the forward tilt in S4, S5(1) and S5(5), the reversed test in S5(4), the "should be refused" triggers, a grid of where the presumption arises with and without a five-year housing supply against the 2024 position, what replaced the 2024 tilted balance, the drafting traps, and a register of 497 decisions with a finding under S4, S5 or S6.

S6: what a neighbourhood plan's age changes, and what it does not

What policy S6 of the August 2026 NPPF does for neighbourhood plans and what it does not: the tilt it adds for a plan made within five years with housing allocations, and the weight a plan keeps under Annex A(2) when S6 does not apply. How inspectors keep the two apart, and how 19 of the 28 Stratford-on-Avon officer reports that reach S6 cut the plan's housing policies to "very limited weight" because S6 is not engaged.

Is there still a tilted balance?

What the December 2024 "tilted balance" was, what a housing land supply shortfall switched on, and what the same shortfall does under the August 2026 NPPF: a grid of 22 situations by location, scale and type, with and without a shortfall, under both Frameworks; the "physically well-related" gate; and who still uses the words, including the Planning Bar.

DP3: the design policy that says "should be refused"

How DP3, the August 2026 NPPF's design policy, is applied: what "should be refused if, without clear justification" means, how it enters the S4, S5 and Green Belt balances, and what 346 decisions show: 162 found DP3 failed and every one was refused or dismissed; only 3 found clear justification.

Local planning authorities

Stratford decisions under the 2026 NPPF: how consistent are they?

How Stratford-on-Avon District Council's planning decisions since the August 2026 NPPF compare with each other and with Planning Inspectorate appeal decisions: DP3(3), heritage harm, Core Strategy CS.8, Green Belt villages and walking routes. Verified quotations and case summaries.

Which Stratford Core Strategy policies keep their weight under the 2026 NPPF

Which Stratford-on-Avon Core Strategy policies keep their weight under the August 2026 NPPF, policy by policy, in the Council's own words: CS.2, CS.4, CS.5, CS.6, CS.9 and CS.12 held consistent; CS.8, CS.10 and CS.22 disputed; CS.15, CS.16, AS.10 and CS.26 held inconsistent. Every quotation checked against the officer reports.

Castle Farm, Studley: an officer report that takes the tests in the Framework's order

The Stratford-on-Avon delegated report on Castle Farm, Studley (25/00989/FUL, refused 30 October 2026), read as an exemplar under the August 2026 NPPF: the order of the tests from Annex A(2) through S5(3), TR3(1)(a), GB6 to GB8, HE4 to HE6 and DP3(3) to the S5(2) balance, with the report's words at each step. The only Stratford report clean on all four recurring errors. Every quotation page-checked.

Four errors in officer reports under the 2026 NPPF: 243 reports from 27 councils scored

Four recurring errors in officer reports under the August 2026 NPPF, first found at Stratford-on-Avon, tested across 243 housing reports from 27 councils on one published rubric: the tier error 7% against 20%, the Green Belt route error 8% against 23%, approval recommended after an unaddressed design conflict 10 times against 17. Warwick repeats the pattern; Bromsgrove and Wychavon do not. Every quotation checked.

Settlements

Land North of Station Road, Claverdon: which test applies?

Why the Green Belt policies GB6 and GB7, not S5, decide planning application 26/01470/FUL at Land North of Station Road, Claverdon, under the August 2026 NPPF; where the scheme fails the TR3 sustainable-location test; the decisions that agree; and a set of answers to load into the NPPF 2026 Navigator.

Greenfingers Nurseries, Kington Lane, Claverdon: a step-by-step assessment

A step-by-step assessment of planning application 26/01831/FUL (10 homes at Greenfingers Nurseries, Kington Lane, Claverdon) against the August 2026 NPPF: the previously developed land and grey belt routes through GB7, the TR3 location test, the Golden Rules, the policies that say development should be refused, the decisions behind each step, and answers to load into the NPPF 2026 Navigator.

Evidence register — Every quotation relied on in the Kington Lane Decision Route for planning application 26/01831/FUL, Claverdon: 219 passages from the application documents, the consultation responses, the council's earlier decisions on the site, the August 2026 NPPF and appeal decisions, each with its document, date and page.

Are sites on Station Road, Claverdon, sustainable?

Route survey of Station Road, Claverdon, for planning application 26/01470/FUL: measured footway widths, video of the walk to Claverdon station, the Connectivity Tool score, and appeal decisions on sustainable location under the August 2026 NPPF.

Which Claverdon Neighbourhood Plan policies keep their weight under the 2026 NPPF

Which policies of the Claverdon Neighbourhood Plan (made December 2019) keep their weight under the August 2026 NPPF: design (BE1), flooding (NE2), valued landscapes (NE1), ecology (NE5), Local Green Space, community facilities, local housing need and brownfield policies do; the heritage policy (BE2) is open to challenge; the housing boundary (H1) is likely to get very limited weight.