Is there still a tilted balance?

What a housing shortfall switched on under the December 2024 NPPF, what it does under the August 2026 Framework, and a grid of 22 situations by location, scale and type showing where each gives a presumption in favour. Decisions to 8 October 2026.

The short answer #

No, not as a rule, but yes in two places. "Tilted balance" was never a phrase in either Framework. It was the profession's name for paragraph 11(d) of the December 2024 text, which told decision-makers to grant permission where the most important plan policies were out of date, unless the harms "significantly and demonstrably" outweighed the benefits. Footnote 8 deemed those policies out of date wherever a council could not show a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites, or its Housing Delivery Test result was below 75%. A housing shortfall therefore suspended the plan's settlement and countryside policies for every housing proposal in the district.

The August 2026 Framework has no "out of date" test and no paragraph 11(d). The words "out of date" appear once, in HO2(5), about neighbourhood housing figures. Decisions inside a settlement go through S4 and outside one through S5, whether supply is healthy or not. The same shortfall now does one thing: it is the standard example of an "evidenced unmet need" in S5(1)(j), and in GB7(1)(g)(ii) for grey belt land. That gives a presumption in favour only where the site is physically well-related to a settlement, or is grey belt land in a sustainable location. Everywhere else the shortfall changes nothing about the starting point.

So the honest description is a tilted balance confined to edge land, rather than one across the district. The grid below shows where. The companion page covers the balance itself, "substantially outweighed", and every decision so far with a finding under S4, S5 or S6.

What a shortfall switched on in 2024 #

Six provisions in the December 2024 Framework turned on the same two facts. The council could not demonstrate a five-year supply with the right buffer, or its Housing Delivery Test result was below 75%.

This includes, for applications involving the provision of housing, situations where: the local planning authority cannot demonstrate a five year supply of deliverable housing sites (with the appropriate buffer as set out in paragraph 78); or where the Housing Delivery Test indicates that the delivery of housing was substantially below (less than 75% of) the housing requirement over the previous three years.

NPPF, December 2024, footnote 8

In 2026 the first three have gone. The buffer ladder survives in Annex D paragraphs 8 to 13 with the same thresholds, except that below 75% now deems an unmet need for S5(1)(j) rather than switching on a presumption. The grey belt test survives in GB7(1)(g) with the same definition in footnote 41. Paragraph 232 survives as Annex A paragraph 3, recast so that a higher standard method figure "should not be considered as evidence of unmet need". The Annual Position Statement has no equivalent.

Where delivery falls below 75% of the requirement over the previous three years, an evidenced unmet need for housing is deemed to exist for the purpose of applying

NPPF, August 2026, Annex D, ¶12(c), which continues "policy S5(1)(j) in this Framework" after a printed page break

Where a shortfall gives a presumption in favour: 22 situations #

A tick means the Framework itself gives the proposal a presumption in favour of approval in that situation: in 2024 the paragraph 11(d) tilt, an accord with an up-to-date plan under 11(c), or paragraph 82's support for rural exception sites; in 2026 policy S4, a category on the S5(1) list, or a GB7(1) category that S5(5) then treats like an S5 proposal. No tick means the plan decides, the Framework presumes against (S5(4) "exceptional circumstances", paragraph 84 or HO11 on isolated homes), or the land is Green Belt where very special circumstances are needed. Hover or focus a cell for the basis.

Presumption in favour No presumption in favour
SituationShortfallNo shortfall
2024202620242026
Outside the Green Belt
Within a settlement boundary, 2 homes infill2024 ¶11(c), ¶11(d) · 2026 S4Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S4: approve unless substantially outweighedNo presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12Presumption in favour: S4: approve unless substantially outweighed
Within a settlement boundary, 20 market homes on an unallocated plot2024 ¶11(c), ¶11(d) · 2026 S4Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S4: approve unless substantially outweighedNo presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12Presumption in favour: S4: approve unless substantially outweighed
Outside a settlement but physically well-related to it, 2 homes on a field2024 ¶11(d), fn 8 · 2026 S5(1)(j)(i), S5(4)Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S5(1)(j)(i): unmet need, well-related, in scaleNo presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12No presumption in favour: S5(4): exceptional circumstances
Outside a settlement but physically well-related to it, 20 market homes with policy-compliant affordable housing2024 ¶11(d), fn 8 · 2026 S5(1)(j)(i), S5(4)Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S5(1)(j)(i): unmet need, well-related, in scaleNo presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12No presumption in favour: S5(4): exceptional circumstances
Adjoining a settlement, rural exception site, affordable-led2024 ¶82 · 2026 S5(1)(f), HO10Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S5(1)(f) with HO10Presumption in favour: ¶82: councils "should support opportunities to bring forward rural exception sites"Presumption in favour: S5(1)(f) with HO10
Outside a settlement, site allocated in the plan2024 ¶11(c) · 2026 S5(1)(i)Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S5(1)(i)Presumption in favour: ¶11(c): accords with an up-to-date plan, approve without delayPresumption in favour: S5(1)(i)
Outside a settlement, within walking distance of a well-connected station2024 ¶11(d) · 2026 S5(1)(h)Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S5(1)(h)No presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12Presumption in favour: S5(1)(h)
Hamlet or group of houses, 2 homes limited infilling2024 ¶11(d) · 2026 S5(1)(e)Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S5(1)(e)No presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12Presumption in favour: S5(1)(e)
Open countryside, 20 homes not well-related to any settlement2024 ¶11(d) · 2026 S5(4)Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8No presumption in favour: S5(4): exceptional circumstancesNo presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12No presumption in favour: S5(4): exceptional circumstances
Open countryside, redundant farmyard (previously developed land) redeveloped for homes2024 ¶11(d) · 2026 S5(1)(d)Presumption in favour: Tilted balance, ¶11(d), switched on by footnote 8Presumption in favour: S5(1)(d)No presumption in favour: Plan decides, ¶11(c) and ¶12Presumption in favour: S5(1)(d)
Open countryside, one isolated home12024 ¶84 · 2026 S5(3), HO11No presumption in favour: ¶11(d) applied in form, but ¶84 says avoid isolated homes unless an exception appliesNo presumption in favour: S5(3): only under HO11No presumption in favour: ¶84No presumption in favour: S5(3): only under HO11
In the Green Belt
Edge of a settlement, grey belt land in a sustainable location, 20 homes22024 ¶155, fn 56, ¶156 · 2026 GB7(1)(g), fn 41, GB8, S5(5)Presumption in favour: ¶155 met, so not inappropriate; then ¶11(d). Golden Rules ¶156Presumption in favour: GB7(1)(g) met; then S5(5). Golden Rules GB8No presumption in favour: ¶155(b) needs a demonstrable unmet need; without it, very special circumstancesNo presumption in favour: GB7(1)(g)(ii) needs an evidenced unmet need; without it, GB6(2)
Edge of a settlement, grey belt land in a sustainable location, 2 homes2024 ¶155, fn 56 · 2026 GB7(1)(g), fn 41, S5(5)Presumption in favour: ¶155 met; then ¶11(d). Not major, so no Golden RulesPresumption in favour: GB7(1)(g) met; then S5(5). Not major, so no GB8No presumption in favour: ¶155(b) needs a demonstrable unmet needNo presumption in favour: GB7(1)(g)(ii) needs an evidenced unmet need
Edge of a settlement, not grey belt, any market housing2024 ¶153, fn 7 · 2026 GB6(2)No presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, ¶153; footnote 7 disapplies the tiltNo presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, GB6(2)No presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, ¶153; footnote 7 disapplies the tiltNo presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, GB6(2)
Edge of a settlement, rural exception site2024 ¶154(f), ¶82 · 2026 GB7(1)(d), S5(5)Presumption in favour: ¶154(f) not inappropriate; then ¶11(d)Presumption in favour: GB7(1)(d); then S5(5)Presumption in favour: ¶154(f) not inappropriate; ¶82 supportPresumption in favour: GB7(1)(d); then S5(5)
Edge of a settlement, not grey belt, within walking distance of a well-connected station2024 ¶153 · 2026 GB7(1)(h), S5(5)No presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, ¶153; footnote 7 disapplies the tiltPresumption in favour: GB7(1)(h); then S5(5)No presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, ¶153; footnote 7 disapplies the tiltPresumption in favour: GB7(1)(h); then S5(5)
Previously developed land, no substantial harm to openness2024 ¶154(g) · 2026 GB7(1)(e), S5(5)Presumption in favour: ¶154(g) not inappropriate; then ¶11(d)Presumption in favour: GB7(1)(e); then S5(5)No presumption in favour: ¶154(g) not inappropriate; plan decidesPresumption in favour: GB7(1)(e); then S5(5)
Open Green Belt away from any settlement, grey belt land, 20 homes32024 ¶155(c) · 2026 GB7(1)(g)(iii), TR3No presumption in favour: ¶155(c) needs a sustainable location, rarely met away from a settlementNo presumption in favour: GB7(1)(g)(iii) needs a sustainable location under TR3No presumption in favour: ¶155(b) and (c) both unmetNo presumption in favour: GB7(1)(g)(ii) and (iii) both unmet
Open Green Belt, one isolated home2024 ¶153, ¶84 · 2026 GB6(2), HO11No presumption in favour: Inappropriate, ¶153; ¶84No presumption in favour: Inappropriate, GB6(2); HO11No presumption in favour: Inappropriate, ¶153; ¶84No presumption in favour: Inappropriate, GB6(2); HO11
Village washed over by the Green Belt, 2 homes limited infilling2024 ¶154(e) · 2026 GB7(1)(c), S5(5)Presumption in favour: ¶154(e) not inappropriate; then ¶11(d)Presumption in favour: GB7(1)(c); then S5(5)No presumption in favour: ¶154(e) not inappropriate; plan decidesPresumption in favour: GB7(1)(c); then S5(5)
Village washed over by the Green Belt, 2 homes not limited infilling, grey belt land42024 ¶155, fn 56 · 2026 GB7(1)(g), fn 41, S5(5)Presumption in favour: ¶155 met; then ¶11(d)Presumption in favour: GB7(1)(g) met; then S5(5)No presumption in favour: ¶155(b) needs a demonstrable unmet needNo presumption in favour: GB7(1)(g)(ii) needs an evidenced unmet need
Village washed over by the Green Belt, 2 or 20 homes not limited infilling, not grey belt2024 ¶153 · 2026 GB6(2)No presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, ¶153; footnote 7 disapplies the tiltNo presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, GB6(2)No presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, ¶153; footnote 7 disapplies the tiltNo presumption in favour: Inappropriate development, very special circumstances, GB6(2)

1 In 2024 the tilted balance formally applied to an isolated home where there was a shortfall, but paragraph 84 told decision-makers to avoid isolated homes unless one of its exceptions applied, so the Framework's own direction was against. In 2026 S5(3) sends an isolated home to HO11 and S5(1)(j) is closed to it: at The Haven 6010187, with a one-year supply, being agreed to be isolated meant the site was not well-related.

2 The Golden Rules apply to major housing on grey belt land in both versions: paragraphs 156 and 157, then GB8.

3 Both versions require a sustainable location for grey belt housing, under paragraphs 110 and 115 in 2024 and under TR3 in 2026. Land away from any settlement will rarely pass, so no tick is shown. A shortfall still makes the attempt possible in both.

4 A washed-over village is not a settlement under the 2026 Annex B definition, so S5(1)(j) is not the route. The route is GB7(1)(g): grey belt land, an unmet need and a sustainable location under TR3, which a village with services can pass. GB7(1)(g) has no "well-related" limb.

Read across the shortfall columns and the two Frameworks agree in most rows. Read down the 2024 columns and the shortfall is a switch: it changes 13 of the 22 rows. Read down the 2026 columns and it changes 5: the two well-related rows outside the Green Belt and the three grey belt rows. In the other 17 rows the two 2026 columns are identical, because the situation has its own S5(1) or GB7(1) category, or none at all. The 2024 "no shortfall" column is blank wherever the answer depends on the local plan, so a council with a permissive edge-of-settlement policy would read some of those cells as ticks.

What is not materially different, and what is #

Not materially different #

  • Grey belt housing. Paragraph 155 and GB7(1)(g) run the same four limbs, and footnotes 56 and 41 define the unmet need identically. "Demonstrable" became "evidenced".
  • Ordinary Green Belt. A shortfall does not unlock land that is not grey belt. Footnote 7 in 2024, S5(5) with GB6 in 2026.
  • The buffer ladder. 5% by default, 20% below 85%, an action plan below 95%, and 20% where an adopted requirement is 80% or less of standard method need. Paragraphs 78 and 79, then Annex D paragraphs 9 and 12.
  • What supply is measured against. The adopted requirement, switching to standard method need once it is over five years old. Footnote 39, then Annex D paragraph 8.
  • The definition of "deliverable". Unchanged apart from adding pitches and plots.
  • Recently adopted plans. Supply plus a Housing Delivery Test above 75% protects a plan from a higher standard method figure for five years. Paragraph 232, then Annex A paragraph 3.
  • Recent neighbourhood plans with allocations. The same two conditions in paragraph 14 and S6, and the same outcome in a shortfall case.
  • Isolated homes and traveller sites. A shortfall never helped an isolated home, and a lack of a five-year supply of traveller sites is an unmet need in both.

Gone or significantly different #

  • The override. Footnote 8 and paragraph 11(d) no longer exist. Nothing is deemed out of date; the plan is not suspended.
  • Inside settlements. S4 approves development within a settlement regardless of supply, so the shortfall adds nothing there.
  • Sites not well-related to a settlement. In 2024 they entered the tilted balance. In 2026 S5(1)(j)(i) shuts them out and they fall to S5(4).
  • The balance test. "Significantly and demonstrably outweigh", with footnote 9's steer to the key policies, becomes "substantially outweighed", the same test every S5 proposal gets.
  • Weight of plan policies. Paragraph 232's reduced weight for out-of-date policies is gone. Annex A paragraph 2 sets weight by consistency with the Framework, so a shortfall council's settlement boundaries keep full weight.
  • The neighbourhood plan shield. Paragraph 14 operated only when the shortfall tilted the balance. S6 operates for every housing proposal that conflicts with a qualifying plan.
  • Below 75% on the Housing Delivery Test. It made "the presumption apply" under paragraph 79(c). Annex D paragraph 12(c) deems an unmet need for S5(1)(j), which still has to pass the proximity and scale limbs.
  • Scope and the Annual Position Statement. Footnote 8 was housing only. S5(1)(j) is "not limited to" housing, with E2(2) on business land. Paragraph 233 has no equivalent.

Development plan policies (or parts of those policies) which are materially inconsistent with national decision-making policies in this Framework should be given very limited weight. The only exception to this is where they have been examined and adopted or made against this Framework. Other development plan policies should not be given reduced weight simply because they were adopted prior to the publication of this Framework.

NPPF, August 2026, Annex A, ¶2

"Physically well-related" is the gate #

Where the 2026 shortfall still tilts, S5(1)(j)(i) decides whether a site gets through. The site must be "physically well-related to an existing settlement" and of a scale the infrastructure can take. That is not the same as being at the edge of a settlement, a phrase neither Framework uses. HO10(2)(a) says an exception site should "adjoin or be physically well-related to a settlement", so the Framework treats the two as different things, and footnote 28 to S5(1)(j) contemplates a site separated from the built-up area by an unbuilt allocation. The term is undefined. The inspector at Old Sarum 6007924 said so before finding a site beside a park and ride, with a footway into the settlement, well-related.

The term ‘physically well related’ is not defined within the Framework.

Old Sarum, appeal 6007924, ¶11
107
decisions in the database with an S5(1)(j) finding
50
in which S5(1)(j) failed
41
of those failed on "well-related" or limb (i)
71
decision letters that use the phrase

Inspectors are reading the limb four ways, and the readings decide cases. Adjoining the settlement edge is strong evidence under the first two and no evidence under the last two.

ReadingDecisionsWhat it looks like
Physical connectivity, not landscape or visual termsWhitchurch 6006893, Lydiard Millicent 6001260Whitchurch passed the limb on connectivity while losing on landscape. Lydiard Millicent passed with 43 m of carriageway walking and no footway, because the policy does not require a site "to adjoin the principal built form".
Settlement form and contiguityCliffe Woods 6004691, Castle Bytham 6007403, Bolney 6009838, Morchard Bishop 6012985Cliffe Woods failed from a site "set away from the defined edge" across a road. Castle Bytham failed from a site adjoining the boundary that spilled over a hedged ridge. Bolney failed on its own access to a remote lane.
Access to services read inFindon 6006900, Roche 6010442, Upper Seagry 6008434, Chavel 6011150Findon failed one dwelling "irrespective of the precise distance" because services were not reachable on foot, by cycle or by bus. Roche failed 280 m from the settlement across a four-lane bypass.
Character and setting read inCastle Bytham 6007403Castle Bytham tied the limb to the "attractive rural setting" of the village and its conservation area.

In physical connectivity, rather than landscape and visual terms, it would be sufficiently well related to the existing settlement and it would be of a scale that could be accommodated taking account the existing and proposed availability of infrastructure.

Whitchurch, appeal 6006893, ¶69

I do not read Policy S5 of the Framework as requiring a site to adjoin the principal built form of a particular settlement or to be served by a continuous segregated footway. Rather, the policy requires an assessment of whether a site is physically well-related to an existing settlement.

Lydiard Millicent, appeal 6001260, ¶24

However, as described, the appeal proposal is set away from the defined edge of Cliffe Woods which is visually contained to the other side of Merryboys Road. The development would visually appear away from the settlement and as part of the countryside with an access from Perry Hill, a distinctly rural road. The development would therefore not appear physically well-related to Cliffe Woods and as such would not meet paragraph 1(j)(i) of Policy S5.

Cliffe Woods, appeal 6004691, ¶15

Nevertheless, the site is not in a location that is reasonably accessible by foot, cycle or public transport to services and facilities required for day-to-day living, and future residents would likely be highly reliant on private cars for most journeys, irrespective of the precise distance. In this context the proposed development would not be physically well related to the settlement of Findon.

Findon, appeal 6006900, ¶17

Two more points fix the limb's reach. It belongs only to S5(1)(h) and (j). At Washington 6009593 the inspector held that limited infilling under S5(1)(e) carries no well-related requirement at all. And it is closed to isolated homes, whatever the supply position.

Policy S5 does not require that proposals for redevelopment of PDL and/or limited infilling within groups of houses are physically well-related to a settlement, since that requirement only appears within parts 1h and 1j, with no indication that it is to be applied to the other forms of development listed.

Washington, appeal 6009593, ¶16

The Council is only able to demonstrate a 1 year housing land supply. The development would therefore contribute towards an evidenced unmet need. However, this alone is insufficient to garner support from policy S5 paragraph 1.j. of the Framework, as the development must be physically well-related to an existing settlement. As it is common ground that the dwelling would be isolated, this criterion is not met.

The Haven, appeal 6010187, ¶30

Grey belt land has no such limb. GB7(1)(g)(iii) asks instead for a sustainable location under TR3, which is covered on the sustainable location page and in the Green Belt tables on the very special circumstances page.

Who still says "tilted balance" #

The words survive in conversation and in advocacy. The decision-makers have stopped using them. Of the 36 summaries in the guidance corpus that mention a tilt, most use the phrase to say what has gone.

The Planning Bar #

Barristers' chambers keep the words, and most of them say the new tilt is steeper. None says the mechanism is the same. Read together, their notes describe a test with a different switch and a different threshold that has inherited a nickname.

Cornerstone Barristers, two days after publication, put both changes in one sentence.

The revised NPPF introduces a tilted-balance on steroids (“substantially” as opposed to “significantly and demonstrably” outweighed); and eschews the trigger for the presumption of plans or policies being “out-of-date”, in favour of a locational-based presumption.

Cornerstone Barristers (Dehon KC, Townsend KC, Williams KC, Lovatt and Sirica), The revised NPPF: navigating the new "rules-based planning system", 19 August 2026, ¶8; also on the chambers' site, 20 August 2026

"On steroids" concedes the point this page makes. A balance that is switched on by location rather than by out-of-date policies, and that sets a different threshold, is not the paragraph 11(d) test. The same chambers' first note on the December 2025 draft had opened "Goodbye to paragraph 11!" and described the S5 list as including "the familiar (failure to demonstrate a five-year housing land supply or scores of less than 75% on the latest Housing Delivery Test) and the new (housing and mixed-use sites within reasonable walking distance of railway stations)" (Unpacking the new NPPF draft, 16 December 2025).

Landmark Chambers has said the most, across a news note, a blog and three webinars. The note on publication day: "Most notably, the “permanent presumption in favour of sustainable development” (policies S3 to S5), which replaces the tilted balance under paragraph 11 of the previous NPPF." (Government publishes new National Planning Policy Framework 2026, 17 August 2026). Zack Simons KC the next day:

In particular, whether the presumption policies at S4 and S5 (more of which next) are triggered is not about time. Or date. Or datedness. It’s about place. And need. And also trains.

Zack Simons KC, #NPPF2026: Welcome to the Future!, #planoraks, 18 August 2026

He keeps the name for the new balance and says the tilt is stronger: "If you fall into one of these S5 categories, then the “tilt” in favour of permission is (and is intended to be) stronger than the previous tilt at §11(d)(ii)." On supply: "There are many more ways of activating this tilted balance than there were before." Nick Grant's slide at the chambers' first webinar on 3 September 2026 summarises S5 as a "Clear list of ‘Tilt On’ development (10 options)" and "Outside of that, tilt the other way (EC)" (NPPF 2026 webinar: An Initial Look, slide 16). Matthew Reed KC's slides at the second webinar, on 24 September 2026, call S4 and S5 "locationally based presumptions, not overarching test as in NPPF24" and S5(1)(j) "a key provision in practice: replacing old need based presumption rendering policies out of date". He cites the Kingston Bagpuize decision below as having "confirmed that other needs beyond 5 HLS engages S5j" (The New NPPF webinar: Placemaking in practice). On whether the new word raises the bar, Reed KC's slides carry the one note of doubt. Of HO7's "substantial weight" for housing he writes "probably not mean greater weight when it was said that ‘significant’ weight under NPPF24", the same substitution of words that S5 makes. Back in January 2026 the chambers' webinar on the draft had asked "Does the S4 and S5 permanent tilt mean more consents?" (Exploring the new NPPF draft, slides, 12 January 2026).

Charles Banner KC, on the Have We Got Planning News For You podcast on 18 August 2026, said of S4 that "the tilt of the of the tilted balance has been increased, the gradient's gone up" and "So, no longer significantly demonstrably, but substantially." On S5(1)(j): "clearly as before a a sub 5-year supply or sub 75% HDT will trigger uh the new tilted balance", but "the previous gateway to the tilted balance, development plan policies being out of date or no relevant policies, that of itself has gone", and a shortfall "isn't the only way to get through". The source is YouTube's automatic transcript, so the wording is as transcribed.

Francis Taylor Building reported on 18 September 2026 that Michael Rhimes, as sole counsel for Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council, had defended the refusal of 115 homes at Whitchurch at a week-long inquiry although the council had no five-year supply (chambers news item; the page refuses automated downloads, so it is described rather than quoted). The decision letter is in the database. On the council's own figures the supply was

This equates to 3.1 years’ worth.

Whitchurch, appeal 6006893, ¶11

and still dismissed the appeal, because conflicts with the "should be refused" policies in N4, DP3 and N2 did what S5(2) says they are likely to do.

Taking these conflicts collectively, there would be substantial adverse effects from approving the proposals that outweigh the collective benefits of the scheme.

Whitchurch, appeal 6006893, ¶79

The day before, at Kingston Bagpuize in the Vale of White Horse, a council with a marginal five-year supply and a Housing Delivery Test result of 192% lost an inquiry for 249 homes, because S5(1)(j) does not need a shortfall.

These are key indicators, but the list is not exhaustive.

Kingston Bagpuize with Southmoor, appeal 6005809, ¶57

In this case, the very marginal five year housing land supply position and the evidenced significant unmet need for affordable housing combine together to indicate that the scheme complies with 2026 Framework Policy S5(1)(j).

Kingston Bagpuize with Southmoor, appeal 6005809, ¶60

Under footnote 8 of the 2024 text the first council would have faced the tilt and the second would not. In September 2026 the outcomes ran the other way. Kings Chambers' two webinars of 19 August 2026 (first session), No5's Bristol seminar of 21 September and 39 Essex Chambers' webinar of 25 August are recordings and programmes without a text, so they are listed here and not quoted.

Three things follow from these notes. The switch is place and need, not the date of the plan. The threshold is a new form of words, which Cornerstone, Simons KC and Banner KC read as a steeper tilt and Reed KC doubts; no inspector or court has yet construed it, and the companion page records that as open. And a housing shortfall is now one way of showing need among several, where in 2024 it was the whole trigger.

Advocacy #

The strongest claim that the old test lives on is an appellant's. SLR Consulting, for Miller Homes at the Colwell Farm inquiry in Mid Sussex, argued on 3 September 2026 that S5 keeps the tilted balance and strengthens it.

S5 maintains the ‘tilted balance’ previously found at NPPF24 11d(ii), but with substantial rather than significant weight placed in favour of development – a materially stronger weighting in favour of development than the previous NPPF24 11d(ii) tilted balance.

SLR Consulting for Miller Homes, Appellant's response on the NPPF 2026, Colwell Farm inquiry document ID32, ¶2.23

"Maintains" is the word the chambers above do not use, and the document's own introduction does not use it either. It says it will consider "S5(1)(j) and HO7, which collectively replace the previous NPPF 11d presumption and provide even clearer direction as to weight" (¶1.5). Even on the appellant's account the test has a different weighting and a different source.

The Ministry itself uses "tilt" for the 2026 presumption, as a description rather than a test. Its response to the consultation records that respondents objected to "substantially outweigh" as the basis "for disapplying the ‘tilt’ in favour of development", and says that an allocation "can be a reason for disapplying the positive tilt in favour of development within settlements".

It has also been clarified that the allocation or safeguarding of buildings, as well as land, can be a reason for disapplying the positive tilt in favour of development within settlements.

MHCLG, Proposed reforms to the National Planning Policy Framework: government response, August 2026

Inspectors #

One letter in the 1,508 decision letters held uses the phrase, and only to describe what happened under the previous Framework.

The Council noted in their planning officer report that they were unable to demonstrate a five-year housing land supply and therefore, the ‘tilted balance’ found at paragraph 11(d) ii, as it was in the previous Framework, was engaged.

Bevercotes, appeal 6007348, ¶42

Councils #

The council sweep holds 3,005 officer report texts. 95 use the phrase, and 30 of those also cite the 2026 policies. Allowing for the same report held twice, that is 19 documents from 11 councils. They fall into five groups.

The 2026 NPPF adopts a different approach to the tilted balance. The national decision-making policies no longer apply the previous test of whether the policies most important for determining an application are out-of-date. Instead, Policies S3–S5 establish the national policy approach to the principle of development according to its location.

Dacorum Borough Council, Land east of Tring, 25/01880/MOA, update report to committee following publication of the 2026 NPPF, ¶3.3

Following updates to the NPPF in August 2026, Footnote 7 removed and the so called ‘tilted balance’ have been removed. The proposal has been considered under the current version of the NPPF and the relevant national decision-making policies within it.

Elmbridge Borough Council, Former Moore Place Golf Course, Esher, 2025/3373, committee report, ¶819

The Authority can demonstrate approximately 5.48 years of deliverable housing land supply, housing delivery has exceeded the identified requirement, and the identified supply of approximately 21,357 dwellings exceeds the plan requirement by approximately 2,505 dwellings. On that basis, the tilted balance is not engaged.

Malvern Hills District Council, Brookfield, Shoulton Lane, Hallow, M/26/01143/PIP, delegated report, 26 August 2026

The fourth group is harmless shorthand. Tonbridge and Malling's two delegated reports say the assessment "will be determined in the context of the tilted balance" and then apply S3 and S4 correctly.

The remainder of the assessment will be determined in the context of the tilted balance and the presumption in favour of sustainable development. As per Policies S3 and S4, development proposals within settlements should be approved unless the benefits of doing so would be substantially outweighed by any adverse effects

Tonbridge and Malling Borough Council, Former Grimbles, Long Mill Lane, Crouch, TM/26/00079/FL, delegated report, ¶5.5

The fifth group is the one that matters. Maldon District Council's committee reports of 2 September, 22 September and 15 October 2026 each find that the council cannot show a five-year supply and conclude that a plan policy is "out of date" and the tilted balance "applied", then run S5(1)(j)(i) and S3 as the new form of the same thing. Basildon Borough Council's report of 7 October 2026 for 19 houses at Knights, Basildon, cites S3, S4 and S5 and then engages paragraph 11.

The tilted balance is therefore applied as policy S2 is currently out of date and not in accordance with the requirements of the NPPF.

Maldon District Council, Land 100m east of 53 Seagers, Great Totham, 25/00607/OUTM, report to committee, 22 September 2026

The Council has published a 2.05 housing land supply position, and as the Council cannot currently demonstrate a five-year housing land supply the “Tilted Balance” of NPPF paragraph 11 is engaged, and this weighs significantly in favour of approving applications for new housing.

Basildon Borough Council, Knights, Basildon, 25/01657/FULL, report to Planning Committee, 7 October 2026, ¶1.5

In Basildon the site is within a settlement, so S4 would have given the same starting point without it. In Maldon the sites are outside settlements and the reasoning does more work: "out of date" is a 2024 concept, and under Annex A paragraph 2 the question is whether the settlement boundary policy is materially inconsistent with the Framework, not whether supply has fallen. The outcome under S5(1)(j) may well be the same. The route is not. These are the carry-overs the four errors page scores across councils.