S6: what a neighbourhood plan's age changes, and what it does not
The one job S6 does, the two conditions it turns on, the weight a plan keeps when S6 does not apply, how inspectors read it, and how one council's reports read it.
The short answer #
S6 does one thing. Where a housing proposal conflicts with a neighbourhood plan that was made in the last five years and allocates sites to meet its housing requirement, the benefits of approving it "are likely to be substantially outweighed by the adverse effects". The presumption in favour of development starts tilted against the scheme.
When S6 does not apply, that tilt is not there. Nothing else changes. The plan is still part of the development plan under section 38(6). Each of its policies keeps the weight Annex A(2) gives it: full weight unless the policy, or a part of it, is materially inconsistent with a national decision-making policy. Annex A(2) says in terms that a policy is not to be given less weight because it is older than the Framework, and its footnote says this covers made neighbourhood plans.
So "S6 is not engaged, therefore the plan's housing policy gets very limited weight" is a non sequitur. The first half is a finding about the tilt. The second half needs a finding about consistency, policy by policy, that the first half does not supply. Inspectors keep the two apart. 19 of the 28 Stratford-on-Avon officer reports that reach S6 do not.
What S6 says #
For development proposals involving the provision of housing, the benefits of approving development are likely to be substantially outweighed by the adverse effects where a proposal would conflict with a neighbourhood plan, provided the following apply:
NPPF, August 2026, S6(1)
The neighbourhood plan became part of the development plan five years or less before the date on which the decision is made; and
NPPF, August 2026, S6(1)(a)
The neighbourhood plan contains allocations to meet its identified housing requirement (see policy HO2).
NPPF, August 2026, S6(1)(b)
Three things follow from the words.
- It is about housing proposals only. A commercial scheme, an extension or a change of use that conflicts with a neighbourhood plan is decided under the plan and the rest of the Framework; S6 says nothing about it.
- Both conditions must hold. A plan made six years ago with every site allocated fails (a). A plan made last year with no allocations fails (b). The requirement in (b) is the figure set for the neighbourhood area under HO2(5), by the local plan or, where the local plan is out of date, as an indicative figure from the local planning authority.
- It is a statement about the balance, not about weight. S6 sits with S4 and S5 in the presumption chapter and uses their formula. It says what is "likely" to happen in the "substantially outweighed" balance when a qualifying plan is in conflict. It does not say what weight any policy carries, and it does not say anything about plans that fail its conditions.
Where it came from #
S6 replaces paragraph 14 of the December 2024 Framework:
In situations where the presumption (at paragraph 11d) applies to applications involving the provision of housing, the adverse impact of allowing development that conflicts with the neighbourhood plan is likely to significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits, provided the following apply:
NPPF, December 2024, ¶14
the neighbourhood plan contains policies and allocations to meet its identified housing requirement (see paragraphs 69-70).
NPPF, December 2024, ¶14(b)
Three changes. Paragraph 14 bit only "in situations where the presumption applies", which under the 2024 Framework meant a plan that was out of date, usually through a housing supply shortfall; S6 attaches to the S4 and S5 balance, which applies to every proposal, so it bites whenever a housing scheme conflicts with a qualifying plan. The formula moved from "significantly and demonstrably outweigh" to "substantially outweighed", like the rest of the presumption (see Is there still a tilted balance?). And condition (b) asks for "allocations" where paragraph 14 asked for "policies and allocations".
The 2024 wording explains a habit that has outlived it. Under paragraph 14, whether a neighbourhood plan's housing policies were "up to date" and whether the paragraph protected them were close to the same question, because the paragraph was the thing that kept them up to date when the district's supply had failed. Stratford-on-Avon District Council's Interim Policy Position Statement of June 2026 read it exactly that way:
Effectively this allows in certain circumstances any housing supply policies contained in Neighbourhood Plans to be treated as being up-to-date even though there is not an adequate land supply across the District as a whole. However, both criteria a) and b) need to be met.
Stratford-on-Avon District Council, Interim Policy Position Statement, June 2026, ¶5.3
Under the 2026 Framework the two questions have come apart. S6 decides the tilt. Annex A(2) decides the weight, and age is not one of its tests.
What S6 does not do #
The weight of a development plan policy under the 2026 Framework is set in one place:
Development plan policies (or parts of those policies) which are materially inconsistent with national decision-making policies in this Framework should be given very limited weight. The only exception to this is where they have been examined and adopted or made against this Framework. Other development plan policies should not be given reduced weight simply because they were adopted prior to the publication of this Framework.
NPPF, August 2026, Annex A(2)
Including policies in made neighbourhood plans.
NPPF, August 2026, Annex A, footnote 67, on "Other development plan policies"
So the decision-maker has two questions, and they are answered on different evidence.
| Question | What it turns on | What the answer changes |
|---|---|---|
| Is S6 engaged? | The date the plan was made, and whether it allocates sites to meet its HO2 requirement. | Whether the S4 or S5 balance starts tilted against a housing scheme that conflicts with the plan. |
| What weight does each policy carry? | Whether that policy, or a part of it, is materially inconsistent with a named national decision-making policy. Not its age. | How much a conflict with the policy counts as an adverse effect in the balance, and under section 38(6) whether the proposal accords with the plan. |
The four combinations are all possible. A recent plan with allocations can hold a boundary policy that is materially inconsistent with S5(1)(j), so the tilt applies to the conflict but the policy itself carries very limited weight. An old plan with no allocations can hold a design, landscape or self-build policy that is wholly consistent with the Framework; there is no tilt, and the policy carries full weight. What a decision cannot do is answer the second question with the first. A finding that S6 is not engaged says nothing about whether any policy contradicts the Framework.
The same point applies to the Core Strategy policies that reports cut for a supply shortfall; see which Core Strategy policies keep their weight. For a plan-by-plan reading of one neighbourhood plan against Annex A(2), see the Claverdon Neighbourhood Plan page.
How inspectors apply it #
The decisions database records 20 decisions with a finding under S6, 8 of them appeal decisions. The inspectors check the two conditions, say which way the tilt runs, and then weigh the plan's policies on their own terms.
Both conditions met: the tilt applies #
Consequently, there is no reason for me to conclude that the Neighbourhood Plan does not continue to make provision for the local housing requirement that was identified at the time it was made, less than five years ago. I therefore give substantial weight to the conflict with Policy 1 of the Neighbourhood Plan.
Menheniot, appeal 6007431, ¶23
Menheniot: plan made April 2022, allocations not yet built but deliverable, appeal dismissed. The inspector weighed the conflict and then applied S6 to the balance.
A condition fails: no tilt, the policy still applies #
Since the HNP became part of the development plan more than five years from the date of my decision, the test at Framework policy S6(a) is not met.
Henfield, appeal 6007104, ¶29
The HNP policies and allocations has made provision for more than the 270 dwellings, thereby exceeding the HNP’s requirement. Therefore, the test at Framework policy S6(b) is met.
Henfield, appeal 6007104, ¶30
Henfield: each limb is tested on its own facts. The inspector then reduced the weight of the conflict with the plan's Policy 1 for a stated reason, that the plan's requirement figure was no longer reliable after a change in circumstances, not because S6(a) had failed.
I emphasise, however, that the NP was adopted in 2017 and therefore it is more than five years old. Therefore, national decision-making policy S6 of the Framework is not applicable in this case.
Buntingford, appeal 6008238, ¶27
Buntingford: the conflict with the plan's Policy HD1 had been found in the sentence before. S6 not applying removed the tilt and nothing else.
Meanwhile, Policy S6 of the Framework does not weigh against the proposal due to the age of the Neighbourhood Plan.
Pitstone, appeal 6010848, ¶33
Pitstone: the effect of a failed condition stated in one line. S6 "does not weigh against the proposal"; the plan's policies are weighed elsewhere in the letter.
One letter reads it backwards #
Where neighbourhood plans have formed part of the development plan within five years of a decision and allocate housing requirements, Policy S6 of the Framework weighs in favour of the benefits of housing proposals over any conflict with that plan.
Pickwell, appeal 6008693, ¶23
Pickwell: S6 tilts against a conflicting housing scheme, not in its favour. The letter then limits the weight of the plan's policies "in outweighing the housing benefits" because the plan is more than five years old, which is the age-for-weight substitution this page is about. The appeal was dismissed on other grounds.
Every decision in the database with an S6 finding (20)
| Decision | Outcome | Finding | Note, as recorded in the case file |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tanworth-in-Arden Committee 26/00410/FUL, 8 Oct 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | NDP made December 2022, within five years, but "does not contain sufficient housing allocations to meet its identified housing need"; NDP H1 then given very limited weight "accordingly" (p.7) |
| Earlswood Delegated 26/01542/FUL, 2 Oct 2026 | refused | S6 not-engaged | neighbourhood plan made 2022 with no housing allocations (p.4) |
| Stratford-upon-Avon Delegated 26/01141/FUL, 2 Oct 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | neighbourhood plan made December 2018 (p.7) |
| Fenny Compton Delegated 26/01801/FUL, 29 Sept 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | neighbourhood plan made 2023 "but does not contain housing allocations (as detailed in the Interim Policy Position Statement)" (p.7) |
| Pickwell Appeal 6008693, 24 Sept 2026 | dismissed | S6 not-engaged | neighbourhood plan made more than five years ago; the letter describes S6 as weighing "in favour of the benefits of housing proposals over any conflict", which inverts S6 (DL 23) |
| Buntingford Appeal 6008238, 24 Sept 2026 | allowed | S6 not-engaged | neighbourhood plan made in 2017, more than five years old (DL 27) |
| Sheepy Parva Appeal 6009220, 23 Sept 2026 | dismissed | S6 fail | conflict with NP; NP said to have become part of development plan five years or less ago and to contain allocations meeting its requirement, so benefits likely substantially outweighed (DL 13-15) — but DL 7 calls it the "2019" NP |
| Henfield Appeal 6006961, 23 Sept 2026 | dismissed | S6 not-engaged | Henfield Neighbourhood Plan passed five years in June 2026, so S6 no longer applies (DL 36) |
| Long Marston Delegated 26/01906/PIP, 22 Sept 2026 | approved | S6 accord | officer states Long Marston NDP is within 5 years and has sufficient allocations, so S6 would bite on any conflict; scheme accords with DEV3 (within BUAB) |
| Pitstone Appeal 6010848, 18 Sept 2026 | dismissed | S6 not-engaged | neighbourhood plan made 2016, more than five years old (DL 33) |
| Tanworth-in-Arden Committee 26/00918/PIP, 11 Sept 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | NDP made 2022 but has no allocations meeting its requirement |
| Welford-on-Avon Committee 26/00772/PIP, 10 Sept 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | NDP made 2017 |
| Snitterfield Committee 26/00617/PIP, 10 Sept 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | NDP made 2018 with no allocations |
| Menheniot Appeal 6007431, 10 Sept 2026 | dismissed | S6(1) fail | NP made April 2022 (within 5 years) with allocations meeting its identified requirement; allocations not yet built but no evidence they cannot be delivered; conflict with NP Policy 1 given substantial weight (DL 21-23) |
| Kislingbury Committee WNS/2022/0673/MAF, 8 Sept 2026 | refused | S6 not-engaged | the 2017 neighbourhood plan is more than five years old, so its boundary and allocation conflict gets very limited weight |
| Biddulph Moor Appeal 6011103, 7 Sept 2026 | allowed | S6 neutral | no evidence to assess; even if engaged benefits outweigh (DL 33) |
| Rockbeare Committee 26/0534/MOUT, 1 Sept 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | Rockbeare NP made Oct 2018 (more than five years old), so conflict with NP Green Wedge and development-limit policies does not trigger S6 |
| Ilmington Delegated 26/01399/PIP, 28 Aug 2026 | refused | S6 neutral | IPPS treats Ilmington NDP (made July 2021, with allocations) as "in date"; significant weight to NDP |
| Southam Committee 25/00346/OUT, 26 Aug 2026 | approved | S6 not-engaged | Southam NDP made 11 Jul 2023 with allocations, but allocations treated as out of date under the IPPS (June 2026), so the allocations limb failed (decided under the old para 14 wording) |
| Henfield Appeal 6007104, 24 Aug 2026 | allowed | S6 not-engaged | S6(a) fails because the HNP was made 23 June 2021, more than 5 years before the decision; S6(b) met (allocations exceed the 270 requirement); NP requirement no longer a credible indicator of need (DL 28-34) |
How Stratford-on-Avon's officer reports apply it #
We have scored every officer report on a housing-type decision issued by Stratford-on-Avon District Council under the August 2026 Framework, 59 reports from 17 August to 5 November 2026, for four recurring errors. The same reports were read again for the neighbourhood plan. 53 of the 59 mention one. 28 are housing reports in which the officer sets out S6, decides whether its conditions are met and has to say what that means for the plan. Four more apply the December 2024 paragraph 14.
The standard sentence #
8 of the 12 reports in the first group use the same two sentences, with only the policy number changed. From the committee report on Ravenstone, Tanworth-in-Arden:
Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H1 very limited weight in the determination of this application.
Ravenstone, Tanworth-in-Arden, 26/00410/FUL, committee report p.7
The first sentence is right: the Tanworth-in-Arden plan was made in December 2022 and the Council holds that its allocations do not meet the area's requirement, so S6(1)(b) fails. The second does not follow from it. "Accordingly" is doing the work that a finding of material inconsistency should do, and no such finding is made. The others in this group are Jago Green, Snitterfield (26/00617/PIP), Butts Lane, Tanworth-in-Arden (26/00918/PIP), Tithe Barn Lane, Earlswood (26/01458/FUL), Malthouse Lane, Earlswood (26/01542/FUL), Bordon Hill, Stratford-upon-Avon (26/01588/PIP), The Slade, Fenny Compton (26/01801/FUL), Fosse Close, Tredington (25/02906/FUL), Gorcott Hill, Beoley (26/01776/OUT), The Hill, Warwick Road, Stratford-upon-Avon (26/01141/FUL), Brook Farm, Abbots Salford (26/01384/FUL), New Street, Napton-on-the-Hill (26/01570/FUL).
A second form names the Annex A(2) test and then applies it to every housing policy in the plan at once. From the committee report on Harbury:
Due to the fact that the NDMPs allow for certain types of development that is not covered in the NDP and is therefore considered to be materially inconsistent, I afford the housing policies in the NDP very limited weight in the determination of this application.
Harbury, 25/02712/OUT, committee report p.11
Annex A(2) cuts "policies (or parts of those policies)" that are materially inconsistent with a national decision-making policy. That the Framework allows some development a plan policy would not is a reason to cut the part of the policy that forbids it, for the sites the Framework reaches, not every housing policy in the plan. The others in this group are Home Farm, Southam (access) (25/00347/FUL), Elm Leys, Welford-on-Avon (26/00772/PIP), Evenlode Close, Stratford-upon-Avon (26/02169/OUT), Park Farm, Aspley Heath (26/01394/PIP), The Paddock, Wood End (26/01717/FUL), Forshaw Heath Lane, Earlswood (25/03083/PIP).
What the cut costs: Napton-on-the-Hill #
Most of the time the cut changes nothing, because the scheme was going to be approved or refused on the Core Strategy or the Green Belt. The delegated report on a self-build home at New Street, Napton-on-the-Hill (26/01570/FUL, approved 5 November 2026) shows what it costs when it does matter. Page 6 finds that the plan's self-build policy has criteria "including encouraging the use of the existing network of public footpaths" and that "I have not found that the proposal demonstrates compliance with this part of the policy". The next paragraph:
It should be noted at this stage that the Neighbourhood Plan is considered to be out of date with regard to housing policies, and as such I can only afford these policies very limited weight in decision making.
Napton-on-the-Hill, 26/01570/FUL, delegated report p.6
The plan was made in July 2021, so S6(1)(a) fails. Nothing in the report says which part of Policy 3 contradicts which national policy; a criterion about footpaths contradicts none. The planning balance on page 10 lists the Core Strategy conflicts and then says "I have not identified any other forms of harm arising from the proposals". The conflict with the plan was found and never weighed. The result would likely have been the same, but the parish's policy was not applied.
The reports that keep the two questions apart #
Eight reports do it as the Framework reads. At Little Kineton the officer finds S6 not engaged (the Kineton plan was made in 2016), then weighs the conflicts with the plan's design and landscape policies and carries them into the refusal:
The proposal does not accord with the Policy requirements for housing as prescribed by Stratford-on-Avon District Core Strategy or the Kineton Neighbourhood Development Plan.
Little Kineton, 26/01561/FUL, delegated report p.18
At Upper Tysoe the officer finds S6 engaged, the Tysoe plan being made in February 2022 with allocations the Council accepts, and resolves a conflict between the plan and the older Core Strategy in the plan's favour:
I therefore consider that NDMP S6 is engaged.
Upper Tysoe, 26/00290/FUL, committee report p.12
The other six are Lucy's Farm, Wootton Wawen (26/01352/FUL), Mount Farm Cottage, Shipston-on-Stour (26/02077/FUL), Whitegates, Earlswood (26/02116/FUL), Warings Green Farm, Hockley Heath (26/01303/FUL), Forest Farm, Long Marston (26/01906/PIP), Church View, Ilmington (26/01399/PIP). In most of them the scheme complied with the plan, so applying it cost nothing; Little Kineton is the one report that finds a plan conflict, keeps it at weight and carries it to a refusal. Ilmington reaches the right weight by the wrong route: it calls the plan "in date" as made in July 2021, but the decision is dated 28 August 2026, so condition (a) had lapsed by six weeks.
The Council's own position #
The revised Interim Policy Position Statement that went to Cabinet on 2 November 2026 works through all 32 made plans against the two conditions: 21 fail on age, 6 are recent but allocate no housing, 2 are recent with allocations that fall short of the Council's requirement figure, and 3 pass, Long Marston, Quinton and Tysoe. It then says what the reports do not:
Equally, where an NDP does not meet the tests of Policy S6, this does not mean that all or any of the NDP policies become irrelevant to the decision. Rather, it would be a matter for the decision maker to balance the benefits and harm and reach a conclusion in the context of each individual application.
Stratford-on-Avon District Council, revised Interim Policy Position Statement, Appendix 1 to the Cabinet report of 2 November 2026, ¶5.13
The absence of the particular protection provided by national policy does not make an NDP irrelevant. Conversely, meeting the tests does not automatically require every conflicting proposal to be refused. A clear explanation of these distinctions is necessary in officer reports and communications with parish and town councils.
The same, ¶8.8
The June 2026 statement had no equivalent sentence. The same paragraph 5.13 goes on to say that a settlement boundary in a plan "is likely to be given very limited weight", which is the Core Strategy reasoning carried into the plans, but the principle is stated: failing S6 does not make a plan's policies irrelevant.
The 32 reports #
Every report that reaches S6, and the four that apply the 2024 paragraph 14, with the sentence that decides the plan's weight and its page. The table is published in the research repository; every quotation is checked against the report text on the page given when this page is built. The remaining 27 reports are householder, commercial, listed building and other cases in which no housing policy of a plan was in play, or no plan is mentioned; none of them names S6.
| Report | Plan | S6 | The words | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S6 not engaged, housing policy cut for that reason or as "out of date" (12) | ||||
| Tithe Barn Lane, Earlswood, 26/01458/FUL delegated, 3 Sept 2026, grant, 1 home | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H3 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.6 | |
| Bordon Hill, Stratford-upon-Avon, 26/01588/PIP committee, 9 Sept 2026, grant, 2 homes | Stratford-upon-Avon made December 2018 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H1 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.6 | |
| Jago Green, Snitterfield, 26/00617/PIP committee, 10 Sept 2026, grant, 1-5 home | Snitterfield made August 2018 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H1 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.9 | Committee report. |
| Butts Lane, Tanworth-in-Arden, 26/00918/PIP committee, 11 Sept 2026, grant, 9 (PIP, 3 to 9) homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H3 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.8 | Committee report. |
| The Slade, Fenny Compton, 26/01801/FUL delegated, 29 Sept 2026, grant, 1 (no net gain over Class Q) home | Fenny Compton made April 2023 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy DE2 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.7 | Plan within five years; no housing allocations. |
| Malthouse Lane, Earlswood, 26/01542/FUL delegated, 2 Oct 2026, refused, 1 home | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H3 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.4 | Refused on other grounds. |
| The Hill, Warwick Road, Stratford-upon-Avon, 26/01141/FUL delegated, 2 Oct 2026, grant, 3 (5 flats to 3 houses, net -2) homes | Stratford-upon-Avon made December 2018 | not engaged | Stratford-upon-Avon NDP was Made in December 2018, and therefore NDMP S6 is not engaged. As such, I afford Policy H1 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.7 | As such for "Accordingly". |
| Ravenstone, Tanworth-in-Arden, 26/00410/FUL committee, 8 Oct 2026, grant, 3 (net 2) homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H1 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.7 | Committee report. The standard two sentences; p.9 adds that the plan "does not meet both tests as set out in NDMP S6 and is materially inconsistent with the Framework". |
| Gorcott Hill, Beoley, 26/01776/OUT delegated, 12 Oct 2026, refused, 2 (self-build) homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | I afford Policy H3 very limited weight in the determination of this applicationp.6 | The two sentences are run together in the text: "Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engagedand I afford Policy H3 very limited weight". Refused on other grounds. |
| Brook Farm, Abbots Salford, 26/01384/FUL delegated, 26 Oct 2026, grant, 1 home | Salford Priors made July 2017 | not engaged | Salford Priors NDP was made in July 2017, and consequently NDMP DS6 is not engaged, and I afford the housing policies in the NDP very limited weight.p.6 | One sentence; "DS6" for S6. |
| Fosse Close, Tredington, 25/02906/FUL committee, 29 Oct 2026, grant, 4 homes | Tredington made July 2023 | not engaged | Consequently, NDMP S6 is not engaged. Accordingly, I afford NDP Policies H1 and H3 very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.8 | Committee report. The report had found the scheme in accordance with H1 and H3 on p.7 before cutting them. |
| New Street, Napton-on-the-Hill, 26/01570/FUL delegated, 5 Nov 2026, grant, 1 (self-build) home | Napton-on-the-Hill made July 2021 | not engaged | It should be noted at this stage that the Neighbourhood Plan is considered to be out of date with regard to housing policies, and as such I can only afford these policies very limited weight in decision making.p.6 | The same page finds the scheme does not comply with Policies 1 and 3; the planning balance on p.10 lists Core Strategy conflicts only and finds no other harm. |
| S6 not engaged, every housing policy cut as "materially inconsistent" (7) | ||||
| Elm Leys, Welford-on-Avon, 26/00772/PIP committee, 10 Sept 2026, grant, 4 (PIP, 1 to 4) homes | Welford-on-Avon made June 2017 | not engaged | I also consider that the NDMPs in Chapter 4 allow for forms of development that would not be supported by Policies HLU1 and HE5 of the NDP (including where there is an evidenced unmet need)p.5 | Committee report. The sentence ends on p.6: "materially inconsistent with the relevant NDMPs. Accordingly, I afford Policies HLU1 and HE[5] very limited weight." |
| Evenlode Close, Stratford-upon-Avon, 26/02169/OUT delegated, 22 Oct 2026, grant, 1 home | Stratford-upon-Avon made December 2018 | not engaged | Accordingly, I afford NDP Policy H1 very limited weight due to the fact that chapter of the Framework permits development that would otherwise be restricted by Policy H1 of the NDP.p.6 | |
| Park Farm, Aspley Heath, 26/01394/PIP delegated, 23 Oct 2026, refused, 6 (net 5) homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | I consider that Policy H3 is materially inconsistent with the national decision-making policies (NDMP) in the Framework should be afforded very limited weight.p.6 | Plan within five years; allocations held not to meet the requirement. Refused on Green Belt grounds, the H3 conflict carried with them at "substantial adverse weight" on p.15. |
| The Paddock, Wood End, 26/01717/FUL delegated, 28 Oct 2026, refused, 3 (lawful 3-pitch traveller site to 3 market homes) homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | I consider that Policy H3 is materially inconsistent with the national decision-making policies (NDMP) in the Framework should be afforded very limited weight.p.8 | Also calls the plan "out of date" for failing S6(1)(b). Refused on Green Belt grounds. |
| Forshaw Heath Lane, Earlswood, 25/03083/PIP delegated, 3 Nov 2026, refused, up to 6 homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | I consider that Policy H3 is materially inconsistent with the national decision-making policies (NDMP) in the Framework should be afforded very limited weight.p.5 | Refused on Green Belt grounds. |
| Home Farm, Southam (access), 25/00347/FUL committee, pending, grant, 0 (access works for 217) homes | Southam made July 2023 | not engaged | Due to the fact that the NDMPs allow for certain types of development that is not covered in the Southam NDP and is therefore considered to be materially inconsistent, I afford the housing policies in the NDP very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.14 | Committee report of 23 September 2026. Plan within five years with allocations; allocations held not to meet the requirement. |
| Harbury, 25/02712/OUT committee, pending, grant, 38 (37 net) homes | Harbury and Deppers Bridge made November 2018 | not engaged | Due to the fact that the NDMPs allow for certain types of development that is not covered in the NDP and is therefore considered to be materially inconsistent, I afford the housing policies in the NDP very limited weight in the determination of this application.p.11 | Committee report. |
| S6 not engaged, conflict found, then neither cut nor weighed (1) | ||||
| Oaks Holt, Kineton, 26/01803/FUL delegated, 4 Nov 2026, refused, 3 (replacement plus 2, net 2) homes | Kineton made October 2016 | not engaged | It would also conflict with NDP Policy H1 given its location and the type of housing proposed.p.5 | S6 found not engaged on p.6. Policy H1 is not mentioned again; the plan's design and landscape policies D1, D2, E2 and E6 are applied at full weight (p.9, p.15). Refused on other grounds. |
| S6 not engaged, plan applied at its Annex A(2) weight (5) | ||||
| Lucy's Farm, Wootton Wawen, 26/01352/FUL delegated, 7 Oct 2026, grant, 0 (replacement dwelling) homes | Wootton Wawen made February 2018 | not engaged | The weight to be given to this conflict is a matter for the planning balance following consideration of other key issues first, including an assessment against Green Belt Policy.p.6 | The conflict is with CS.20, AS.10 and Policy H1 of the plan, found on the same page straight after "NDMP S6 is not engaged." |
| Little Kineton, 26/01561/FUL delegated, 23 Oct 2026, refused, 1 (self-build) home | Kineton made October 2016 | not engaged | The proposal does not accord with the Policy requirements for housing as prescribed by Stratford-on-Avon District Core Strategy or the Kineton Neighbourhood Development Plan.p.18 | S6 found not engaged on p.7 ("NDMP S6 is therefore not engaged."). Conflicts with plan policies D1, D2 and D10 are weighed on p.17 and carried into the refusal reasons on p.18 and p.19. |
| Mount Farm Cottage, Shipston-on-Stour, 26/02077/FUL delegated, 28 Oct 2026, grant, 1 home | Shipston-on-Stour made October 2018 | not engaged | The proposed development is considered to comply with Core Strategy policy CS.5 and CS.6 and NDP Policy NA.4.p.8 | S6 found not engaged on p.5; no housing-policy conflict; the plan's policies applied as they stand. |
| Whitegates, Earlswood, 26/02116/FUL delegated, 29 Oct 2026, grant, 0 (replacement dwelling) homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | in this instance the application is for a replacement dwelling which I consider is materially consistent with the requirements of the NDPp.4 | Replacement dwelling; found to accord with Policy H3 of the plan on the same page. |
| Warings Green Farm, Hockley Heath, 26/01303/FUL delegated, 30 Oct 2026, refused, 3 (conversion) homes | Tanworth-in-Arden made December 2022 | not engaged | I am satisfied that both the Core Strategy and the Neighbourhood Development Plan Policies, and the policies contained therein, are materially consistent with the requirements of the NPPF.p.9 | S6 found not engaged on p.7 on the allocations condition; the plan's policies then applied at full weight. |
| S6 engaged or the plan treated as in date, plan applied (3) | ||||
| Church View, Ilmington, 26/01399/PIP delegated, 28 Aug 2026, refused, 1 home | Ilmington made July 2021 | "in date" | it is therefore considered to be in date' and significant weight can therefore be attributed to the NDP policiesp.5 | Wrong on the date: the plan was made on 12 July 2021 and the decision is dated 28 August 2026, so condition (a) had lapsed. Right on the weight: the conflict with Policy HA.1 is carried to the refusal (p.11). |
| Forest Farm, Long Marston, 26/01906/PIP delegated, 22 Sept 2026, grant, 1 home | Long Marston made April 2024 | engaged | the Long Marston became part of the development plan within 5 years and contains sufficient housing allocations and therefore any conflicts with such NDP policies would likely result in substantial harmsp.5 | The scheme accords with Policy DEV3, so the tilt is not reached. The same report misdescribes S6 on p.4 as the test for emerging policies. |
| Upper Tysoe, 26/00290/FUL committee, 21 Oct 2026, grant, 2 homes | Tysoe made February 2022 | engaged | I therefore consider that NDMP S6 is engaged.p.12 | Committee report. The scheme accords with Policy H1 (p.13); the conflict between the plan and the Core Strategy resolved in the plan's favour under section 38(5). |
| December 2024 paragraph 14 applied, plan "out of date" (4) | ||||
| Pittern Hill, Kineton, 26/01764/PIP delegated, 25 Aug 2026, grant, up to 6 homes | Kineton made October 2016 | not raised | Kineton has a Neighbourhood Development Plan which was adopted in 2016 and is therefore now considered to be out of date.p.11 | Neither S6 nor paragraph 14 is cited; age alone. |
| Long Compton, 25/02369/FUL committee, 27 Aug 2026, other, 7 homes | Long Compton made April 2016 | ¶14 (2024) | Accordingly, as the Long Compton NDP was made over five years ago, it is considered to be out of date.p.17 | Committee report of 22 July 2026 under paragraph 14 of the December 2024 Framework (p.7); decided 27 August 2026. |
| Home Farm, Southam, 25/00346/OUT committee, pending, grant, 217 homes | Southam made July 2023 | ¶14 (2024) | Whilst there are housing allocations in this NDP, they are considered to be out-of-date with regard to housing land supply.p.12 | Committee report of 26 August 2026 under the December 2024 paragraph 14: "As such, paragraph 14 is not engaged." Conflicts with the plan carried to the balance as out-of-date policies. |
| Alcester Road, Shottery, 25/01649/FUL committee, pending, grant, 65 (100% affordable) homes | Stratford-upon-Avon made December 2018 | ¶14 (2024) | It is also noted that the NDP policies are out of date, due to the NDP being adopted in excess of 5 years ago.p.32 | Committee report under paragraph 14 of the December 2024 Framework (p.13). |
What a report should say #
- Run S6 and say what it does. Give the date the plan was made and whether its allocations meet the HO2(5) requirement. If both conditions hold, the S4 or S5 balance starts tilted against a conflicting housing scheme. If either fails, it does not. Stop there: that is the whole of S6.
- Take each relevant plan policy on its own. Ask whether any part of it is materially inconsistent with a named national decision-making policy. A boundary policy that forbids what S5(1)(j) or GB7(1)(g) allows is inconsistent to that extent; a design, landscape, heritage, footpath or self-build criterion usually is not. Give very limited weight to the inconsistent part and full weight to the rest. Do not mention the plan's age.
- Carry the conflict into the balance. A conflict with a full-weight policy is an adverse effect under S4(1) or S5(1), and a departure from the development plan under section 38(6). Say so, and say what weight it gets.
Two sentences would do it at Napton: "S6 is not engaged, because the plan was made in July 2021. Policy 3's footpath criterion is consistent with the Framework and carries full weight; the proposal does not meet it, and I weigh that conflict as a moderate adverse effect."