← Service Village Does Not Mean Sustainable

C · Tier cited in support, beside route or transport evidence

Cedars Farm, Broadwas

6010973·Malvern Hills·11 Sept 2026allowed·M/25/00216/FUL

Tier label used

Category 2 settlement / key services

The tier sentence ¶9

“Broadwas is defined, in Annex B, as a Category 2 settlement as it has at”

The route sentence ¶17

“the public house, school, recreation field, and bus stops are all within walking distance of the appeal site and there is a doctor's surgery within cycling distance, even if this would only be suitable for competent and confident cyclists”

Summary

One house on a paddock between two existing houses just outside the Broadwas development boundary, in a district with a five-year supply and a plan adopted in March 2026. Allowed. The inspector held the plot to be "limited infilling within groups of houses" under S5(1)(e), found the location acceptable for one dwelling given walkable village facilities and buses, and treated S5(1)(e) as a material consideration outweighing conflict with the brand-new local plan's boundary policy.

The location finding

  • TR3: pass. pub, school, recreation field and bus stops walkable; GP cyclable; car reliance no worse than existing residents; one house generates little movement (DL 16-20)

Why this is cited

Category 2 (two key services, daily bus) supported the location and the bus was tested as a genuine alternative; allowed. In the register this counts as a case where the tier was cited in support of the scheme beside route or transport evidence.

One entry in a register of 203 decisions that matched the search for a settlement-tier label, each read at every matching passage and classified by how the label influenced the decision. The quotation was checked against the source named above. Not legal advice. © Planning Distilled. Text, data and images on this page are released under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence: share and adapt them freely, with credit to Planning Distilled. Quotations from decision letters, plans and the Framework remain the copyright of their publishers. Source and data: github.com/planningdistilled/research.